My Rating: 4 Stars
Here’s why
I have not actually read Jane Eyre, but I was excited to see this retelling of the classic story as a December 2020 Book of the Month selection.
Jane is new to the Birmingham area and finds herself walking dogs for the residents of the prestigious Thorfield Estates – a rich, uppity gated community full of McMansions, fancy SUVs and gossipy housewives. When Jane catches the eye of newly-widowed Edward “Eddie” Rochester, their romance moves quickly as they fall hard and fast for one another. However, Eddie’s late wife, Bea, still seems to haunt their lives as the successful rags-to-riches owner of the interior design company Southern Manors. Can Jane fully win over Eddie’s heart or will her past – and his – taint their futures?
***
When I first read a synopsis for this book I immediately thought of Rebecca by Daphne Du Maurier, which I read earlier this year.
The widowed husband, mysterious death of/missing wife, a new love entering their world, it seemed too similar for my liking. However, reading it now for myself, it isn’t exactly the same. Plus, comparing the plot to a short summary I read of Jane Eyre, I can see where Hawkins decided to take some liberties whilst keeping some plot points, names, and characters the same.
I am giving this book 4/5 Stars because I really enjoyed the writing (I read it in 24 hours!), the plot line was intriguing, and I loved that it gave me Gone Girl/Rebecca vibes. Both great novels with great, twisted characters. I am not giving it 5 stars because I wish there was one more chapter/sneak peek into the characterβs lives to tie up all the loose ends!Β
If you love retellings of classics, or stories like Gone Girl and Rebecca, you will love The Wife Upstairs!
HAPPY READING π
Genre: Thriller/Mystery/Fiction/Retelling/Classic/Adult